“We are going to complain that as Palestinians we have been under occupation for 63 years.”
Evelyn Gordon har skrivit om detta uttalande i Commenary Magazine, Abbas Revealing Statement:
For anyone who needs reminding, Israel’s “occupation” of the West Bank and Gaza began 44 years ago, in 1967. What happened 63 years ago was Israel’s establishment – in the pre-1967 borders. In other words, as far as Abbas is concerned, the problem isn’t Israel’s “occupation” of the West Bank, it’s Israel’s very existence: Even pre-1967 Israel constitutes an “occupation.”.
Palestiniernas president, den påstått moderata fredspartner för Israel, anser alltså att Israels bildande var starten på "ockupationen". Men araberna i palestina har aldrig haft en egen stat. Gordon kommenterar:
The charitable might say Abbas was simply referring to the Palestinians’ 63 years without a state: At the same time Israel was established, in 1948, Jordan and Egypt occupied the West Bank and Gaza, respectively.
But in reality, there has never been an independent Palestinian state; Palestinians have always lived under someone else’s rule. Before 1948 came the 31-year British occupation; before that came the 400-year Turkish occupation; before that came various Arab caliphates that ruled “Palestine” from Damascus; and so forth.
In short, 63 years doesn’t mark the start of Palestinian life under occupation –unless you think Israel’s very existence, and only that, constitutes an occupation.
Länken kom via Challah Hu Akbar.